Beware of Excessive Tylenol Pain And Spine Care Here's how to make Tylenol work way better Dose it correctly: 1,000 mg at a time, spaced every 8 hours. Smaller doses don't control pain as well. Take it When Good Drugs Go Bad: Acetaminophen Toxicity tl;dr pharmacy Tylenol and Glutathione: Myths Debunked Yes there is good evidence that acetaminophen (the active ingredient in Tylenol) can deplete glutathione under certain conditions. But whether that matters depends on dose, duration, and individual factors.